STRANGEly fascinating

Wow, I really loved Marvel's STRANGE TALES #1.

If this was an attempt to "counter-program" DC's WEDNESDAY COMICS, it's a pretty solid drubbing -- there's a tremendous amount of energy and passion on display on most of the strips here that I'm finding lacking from WC (which is beautiful, and all, but I found myself suddenly stopping reading WC at around week 3, saying I'll read again when the whole thing is complete, which I guess will get me there around 9/23)

Like with most anthologies, there's not a lot here of real lasting and permanent value, but even the slightest pieces are inventive and fun -- for example, Paul Pope's "Inhumans" story is nearly an episode of Seinfeld on the nothing-happens scale; it is eight pages about trying to open a can of dog food... but what a glorius eight pages it is!

There's some seriously mental work on here: who would have ever (EVER!) thought you'd see a Junko Mizuno or Jason "Spider-Man" story? Or Dash Shaw doing "Dr. Strange"? Man, pure beauty!

There were a few bits that didn't work for me: I thought the Johnny Ryan pages weren't "Johnny Ryan enough" -- I wanted to see more feces and blood and cursing! And I was oddly cold from the Peter Bagge "Hulk" story, especially for something that was so famously "drawered" for being... too something or another. While his "Megalomaniacal Spider-Man" was pretty on-the-nose, this first third of "Hulk" almost felt too sit-com-y for my taste.

The real winner for me, however, was Nick Bertozzi's "M.O.D.O.K." story, which got me dangerously close to a tear. It was a real winner. IN fact, between that and the Pope story, it seems to me that these cartoonists are probably better off to not do the "big" Marvel characters, as there is more to be mined from the c-listers.

I don't know really how to rack this book -- it doesn't belong in the Marvel section of the store at all. Marvel's standard readership isn't going to know how to react to this book, whatsoever, and I don't think it will be all that great to "lead" Marvel readers to a wider set of styles.

Its also a book that seems to REQUIRE hand-selling -- at least three quarters of the people I pointed to it had no idea it was out (even staring them in the face), but each of them was "Holy Shit! I want!!"

Am I the only person who finds it deeply ironic that this came out the same week as the announcement of the Disney deal? I wouldn't count a lot on projects like this coming too much in the New World Order, but maybe I'll be surprised?

Overall, I thought this was an EXCELLENT comic book. What did YOU think?

-B

Arriving THURSDAY 9/10/2009

Please do not forget that, thanks to Labor Day, New Comics Day in the US is not until THURSDAY this week!

2000 AD PACK AUG 2009
2000 AD PACK JUL 2009
ADVENTURE COMICS #2
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #604
ANGEL ONLY HUMAN #2 (OF 4)
ARCHIE & FRIENDS #135
ARCHIE DIGEST #257
BLACKEST NIGHT BATMAN #2 (OF 3)
BOOSTER GOLD #24
BPRD 1947 #3 (OF 5)
CARTOON NETWORK ACTION PACK #41
COMPLETE DRACULA #3 (OF 5)
DARK AVENGERS/UNCANNY X-MEN EXODUS DAX
DARK REIGN LIST AVENGERS ONE SHOT
DARK REIGN YOUNG AVENGERS #4 (OF 5) DKR
DEAD #4 KINGDOM OF FLIES
DEAD AT 17 AFTERBIRTH #4 (OF 4)
DEAD SPACE EXTRACTION (ONE SHOT)
DESCENDANT #3 (OF 3)
DMZ #45
DOCTOR WHO ONGOING #3
DOOM PATROL #2
ELEPHANTMEN #21 (RES)
ENDERS GAME COMMAND SCHOOL #1 (OF 5)
FALLEN ANGEL REBORN #3
FARSCAPE DARGOS TRIAL #2
FINDING NEMO REEF RESCUE #3 (OF 4)
FREDDY JASON ASH NIGHTMARE WARRIORS #3 (OF 6)
G-MAN CAPE CRISIS #2 (OF 5)
GREEN LANTERN CORPS #40 (BLACKEST NIGHT)
HELLBOY WILD HUNT #6 (OF 8)
HOUSE OF MYSTERY #17
HULK TEAM-UP ONE SHOT
INCREDIBLE HERCULES #134
KICK ASS #7
LIFE AND TIMES OF SAVIOR 28 #5
LILLIM #5 (OF 5)
MARVEL ADVENTURES SUPER HEROES #15
MARVEL SUPER HERO SQUAD #1 (OF 4)
MARVEL ZOMBIES RETURN #2
MARVELS PROJECT #2 (OF 8)
MAURA #2
MODELS INC #1 (OF 4) (RES)
MUPPET ROBIN HOOD #4 (OF 4)
NOMAD GIRL WITHOUT A WORLD #1 (OF 4)
POLITICAL POWER #2 BARACK OBAMA BK MKT ED
PUNISHER FRANK CASTLE MAX #74
RED HERRING #2 (OF 6)
RED ROBIN #4
RED SONJA #48
ROTTEN #3
SECRET SIX #13
SHIELD #1
SONIC THE HEDGEHOG #204
STAR TREK NERO #2
STORMWATCH PHD #23
SUPERMAN WORLD OF NEW KRYPTON #7 (OF 12)
THICKER THAN BLOOD #3 (OF 3) (RES)
THOR TALES OF ASGARD BY LEE & KIRBY #5 (OF 6)
THUNDERBOLTS #135 DKR
TITANS #17
TYRESE GIBSONS MAYHEM #2 (OF 3)
ULTIMATE COMICS AVENGERS #2
UNWRITTEN #5
VAMPIRELLA SECOND COMING #1 SUYDAM CVR
WAR OF KINGS WHO WILL RULE ONE-SHOT
WARLORD #6
WEDNESDAY COMICS #10 (OF 12)
WITCHBLADE #130 SEJIC CVR A
X-MEN FOREVER #7

Books / Mags / Stuff
ACHEWOOD HC VOL 02 WORST SONG PLAYED
ALL & SUNDRY UNCOLLECTED WORK HC 2004-2009
ANGEL AFTER THE FALL HC VOL 05 AFTERMATH
CAPTAIN BRITAIN AND MI 13 TP VOL 03 VAMPIRE STATE
CINEFEX #119 OCT 2009
CLASSIC MARVEL FIGURINE COLL MAG #100 BANSHEE
DC SUPERHERO FIGURINE COLL MAG #17 STARFIRE
DC SUPERHERO FIGURINE COLL MAG #20 BOOSTER GOLD
EMILY THE STRANGE TP VOL 02
FANTASTIC FOUR LOST ADVENTURES BY STAN LEE TP
FULL FRONTAL NERDITY TP VOL 02 YOUVE GOT THE TOUCH
GIRAFFES IN MY HAIR A ROCK N ROLL LIFE HC
GOTHAM CENTRAL HC VOL 02 JOKERS AND MADMEN
GRIMWOODS DAUGHTER HC
GUARDIANS OF GALAXY TP VOL 02 WAR OF KINGS BOOK 01
JAMES ROBINSONS COMPLETE WILDCATS TP (RES)
JUDGE DREDD COMPLETE CASE FILES TP VOL 13
JUDGE DREDD MEGAZINE #288
LIFE & TIMES MARTHA WASHINGTON IN 21ST CENTURY HC
LITTLE LULU TP VOL 20 BAWLPLAYERS & OTHER STORIES
LOVE & ROCKETS NEW STORIES TP VOL 02
MARVEL 1602 PREM HC
MARVEL SUPERHERO TEAM UP TP
PAUL THE SAMURAI COMPLETE WORKS TP
RED MONKEY DOUBLE HAPPINESS BOOK HC
RUNAWAYS GOOD DIE YOUNG PREM HC
SAVAGE SWORD OF CONAN TP VOL 06
SQUIRREL MACHINE HC
STRONTIUM DOG TRAITOR TO HIS KIND TP
SUPER HUMAN RESOURCES TP SEASON 01
TANGENT SUPERMANS REIGN TP VOL 02
TOYFARE #147 DC DIRECT BATMAN CVR
ULTIMATUM SPIDER-MAN PREM HC
WEST COAST BLUES HC
X-MEN MISFITS GN VOL 01
YOTSUBA & ! GN VOL 01
YTHAQ PREM HC NO ESCAPE

What looks good to YOU?

-B

Abhay: "3 Jacks" by Ann Nocenti, David Aja, Matt Hollingsworth, and Chris Eliopoulos

So, “3 Jacks”—pretty much the best Marvel comic of the year so far, right? Tim O’Neil agrees; I agree; I don’t know who else has weighed in. “3 Jacks” is a 13-page back-up feature in DAREDEVIL #500, created by Ann Nocenti, David Aja, Matt Hollingsworth and Chris Eliopoulos. The rest of the comic is inert; not worth anyone’s time. But: “3 Jacks,” everybody! Where do we start? Well, let’s start with the first page.

d21y The opening panel: buildings in silhouette, with the Coney Island Parachute Jump tower above the skyline. I don’t know much about the Parachute Jump tower, but: at the angle chosen, the way Aja draws it, does it resembles a cross to you?

Our metal-crucifix is located dead center on the page, not off to the side, not one detail of many—dead center. Flanking it, we have two panels: one, a woman praying in silhouette; the other, a man yelling “Keep ‘Im Close, Damn It” to the heavens. Both characters point in direct lines towards the cross; both are talking to God in their own way.

(Maybe that's something representative of Nocenti’s run on DAREDEVIL in general-- an absurdly straight-faced religious image on one end of a teeter-totter, with an almost-corny image straight out of Will Eisner keeping it in balance? Maybe; not for me to say: a handful of issues of her DAREDEVIL run made an impression on me, but I don’t think I’ve ever read that entire run tip-to-toe. I have no claims to being an expert on the Nocenti run, and this essay will unfortunately be limited as such).

The other panels? A small set of visual jokes: (i) a panel of a bullseye but with no way of telling if it's from the villain's mask or the poster with “Live Human Target” scrawled on it; (ii) a poster for the “Human Blockhead” a panel away from Daredevil being struck in the head; (iii) my favorite is the word “Clone” cut off from the window of what we’re later told is the “Cyclone Bar”—I don’t know if that’s a joke by David Aja & Chris Eliopoulos on Aja’s appropriation of Dave Mazzucchelli’s style circa 1980-whatever, but I’d like to think Aja & Eliopoulos were being self-deprecating.

* * *

So we open with a distant steel God towering over moments solemn, and silly, and empty, and violent, with a man in a devil costume as far from God on the page as can be (his arms also akimbo though). Fine; that’s nice. How does the comic end? Does Daredevil win the spiritual battle the first page sets out? Well: let’s skip to the end! Here’s the last panel:

d22o Again, we see the Parachute Tower but the angle is different. The skyline is higher—and the man in the devil costume is now at the center of page, the city on one end of him, the crucifix on the other, restored to equilibrium, in balance with his environment … though there’s still a gap between him and that crucifix, still that gap. He’s almost a silhouette like the rest of his environment, but no, not quite—colorist Matt Hollingsworth makes sure there’s still just that tiniest hint of red. A little taint of sin that’s not washing off, a little bit of the devil costume peeking through.

Is that last panel a spoiler? No: because that panel in fact is shown on the page immediately preceding the story.

The story of 3 Jacks is there’s a fight between Bullseye and Daredevil at the Coney Island amusement park, and then that fight ends and Daredevil runs off into the night. The end.

But the way that story is structured is this: we start with the end of the fight, the story goes beyond the end of the fight as we watch Daredevil recover from the fight with two people who have witnessed the fight, Larry and Gina. Larry, Gina and Daredevil then talk about the middle of the fight which we see in flashback (we never see the beginning of the fight; the beginning of the fight doesn’t matter—Daredevil and Bullseye will always be fighting).

When we finally reach the ending? We wind up back where we started from-- like I said: the last image of the story is the same image as on the page literally preceding the story itself. It’s like a spiral.

hitch

The comic is about a character trapped in a spiral of violence, not explicitly but in the form the story is presented. Daredevil has no way out of that spiral-- the only thing his story can ever be about is the process of Daredevil picking himself up and running into battle again. Not just a spiral of violence: maybe one way to look at the story is it's about how Daredevil is in a loop of constantly being knocked out of spiritual alignment and struggling to restore his relationship with his faith.

So, wait: I'm making "3 Jacks" sound like a totally boring bummer about, like, Jesus or something, aren't I? It's not that. You get to see Daredevil use his radar powers and his lie-detecting powers. Daredevil kicks Bullseye in the face. Daredevil fights Bullseye throughout the comic. The Marvel comics goods are delivered in those 13 pages, besides everything else that’s going on. And by David Aja, Matt Hollingsworth and Chris Eliopoulos, no less. Silent pages, silhouette flashbacks, heartbeat scrawls, graphic shapes, extreme close-ups on big-wide-open eyes, etc. Aaah, comics, everybody…

Plus: I just like Larry and Gina, the two witnesss I mentioned before, the praying girl and the yelling guy from the first page. They represent aspects of Daredevil’s father and mother. But besides that? They’re just funny characters in their own right. There’s comic business with a hammer; the 10 Commandments are re-written; Larry and Gina have interesting things to say for themselves. It’s not an extraordinary amount of characterization. It’s a Daredevil comic, and Larry & Gina are stock comic book characters—“precocious schoolgirl” and “washed-up boxer” don't exactly break new ground. But, you know: they’re really not the worst company you could ask for from a Marvel comic. The lead story of the issue is about ninjas screaming at each other; I’m happy to stick with Larry and Gina instead.

* * *

The heart of the comic is Bullseye has thrown three photos into Daredevil’s chest, saying “Dead Center! You just don’t’ know it yet” as he did so.

d23a The three photos turn out to be meaningful to Daredevil—to the reader, too, if they knows their Daredevil “lore.” If they can put images into context.

Which: I mean, that’s kind of writing comics right there, isn’t it? You pick out still images, little bits of the past frozen in time, and you throw them into another person, hope they stick…? If Ann Nocenti is a character in this story, she’s not the old yelling-guy or the praying girl or the distant steel God; she’s Bullseye. She can’t kill Daredevil—all she can do is hurt him as much as she can. “Dead Center! You just don’t know it yet.” She’s sort of bragging about how good a job she’s doing in the story itself, man. Shit, I kind of dig that.

* * *

There’s more: Daredevil, Larry and Gina are all dealing with their relationships with their parents (which I’m thinking might possibly be metaphorical); Daredevil is "saved" by the prayers of a girl who “hates God” and Larry pleading to a cross to "Keep 'Im Close"; that fantastic page of Gina lying to Daredevil (if I understood the concept of grace, let alone cared, maybe I’d have something to say there); the final images of Larry with a hammer in his hands, which… carpentry? Isn’t that something? You know: from the Bible or Jesus or one of those? Or wait: maybe I’m thinking of that show HOME IMPROVEMENT? Maybe "3 JACKS" is actually a metaphor for how men are pigs HARF HARF HARF (am I right, ladies?). It’s 13 pages, but I'll be damned if it isn't a dense fucker.

Tim O'Neil concluded his review by stating "If Marvel publishes a better story this year I'll eat my hat." I'll go one better: if Marvel publishes a better story this year, Tim O'Neil will eat every article of clothing in my closet, at gunpoint. It's your move, MARVEL DIVAS. Winner takes O'Neil.

* * *

MISCELLANEOUS NOTES ABOUT THE REST OF THE ISSUE:

** Some crap about ninjas, again...?

** What’s the story with Billy Tan’s pages here? They're not professional-quality comic pages. If I had to guess, I’d guess they’d lined up a real talent for this List comic, but the real talent blew it, something came up, Ashton Kutcher's next movie needed a hovercraft designed, whatever; yaddah yaddah yaddah, some editor goes to Tan at the last minute and asked him to rush out pages. That would be my guess what happened, if I had to make a guess. That would be as nice a thing as I could say about Billy Tan's work here: maybe an editor forced him to do that. Or an alternate theory: maybe someone lost a bet. You know, like one of those TRADING PLACES bets. Maybe someone bet Don Ameche $1 that if they gave Billy Tan a real comic book artist's job, he would start to draw like a real comic book artist. Don Ameche won that one; Don Ameche's the big winner. Except... except for the being dead part. Don Ameche: no longer with us. Great in HEAVEN CAN WAIT. But very, very dead. But dead and one U.S. dollar richer, so who's laughing? Well, not Don Ameche. He's dead. I mean, it's kind of a bummer if you think about it, Don Ameche being dead, or just death in general. That's nothing to laugh about. That's sad, really. He was really great in HEAVEN CAN WAIT. It's all just so temporary. We'll never know how Don Ameche would have spent his Billy Tan dollar. You know, this all seemed like a very simple joke at first, but fucker sort of got away from me, I don't know what to tell you...

** The Brubaker DAREDEVIL run ended in the issue. For me, and this is completely unfair, but: that run was like watching air rush out of a balloon. It started so well with that prison arc, but—and this is the unfair part: Mr. Fear…? NO, THANK YOU. As soon as Mr. Fear showed up, I split. How unfair is that? I’ll read all manners of crap, just the crappiest crap that ever crapped, without complaint, happy as can be, but: “Mr. Fear? No, no: fuck you. Daredevil was better back when he fought the guy who was like an Owl, but I am not putting up with this Mr. Fear horse-shit. Fuck you, God!” What a terrible job it is to write mainstream comics. How could Ed Brubaker or anyone conceivably see that I’d draw the line super-arbitrarily at Mr. Fear? There’s no earthly way Ed Brubaker could ever guess that in a million years. And yet: I blame him anyways.

** The last Ed Brubaker comic I read was that new Captain America thing where it was all “Hey, Captain America—we have to get you back to the island using the Constant Sawyer Hurley.” Which was a nice comic, but I remember thinking, “Hey, maybe Ed Brubaker watches that show LOST.” And then Daredevil #500—was it just me or did his story have an identical flashback structure to the season finale of LOST? It was probably written before the finale—or maybe, but…? Am I just seeing things? It's probably just a coincidence. I’m probably just seeing things. Still: I hope the next issue of CRIMINAL explains what that crazy smoke monster is. Smoke monster is my favorite character.

** Or here’s a theory: maybe the night before his pages were due, Billy Tan was walking down a street when he saw a psychotic clown trying to rape a little kid. And he was like, “Get off that kid, Bozo! I’ll make you a sad clown. WITH MY BILLY TAN FISTS.” And then they fought, like bare-knuckles, all night long, man versus clown, and yeah, Billy Tan named his fists after himself, but I think that’s manly, why not. (The clown in this story symbolizes the Buddha on the road; I learned it from reading you, Ann Nocenti). And he wins in the end, Billy Tan wins and saves the kid from being clown-molested, but the price is DARK LIST pages you can look at without feeling sadness in your eyeballs. But that’s a small price to pay. Maybe we all owe Billy Tan an apology. He very well might be a hero to children everywhere, including the child inside all of us. The child inside all of us that is deathly afraid of a clown touching our peener without consent.

** Wait, wait: if Disney owns ABC, and ABC has LOST on it, does that mean Marvel comics kind of does own the Smoke Monster? Smoke Monster's my favorite character.

** Why did Lynn Varley’s colors get destroyed in the reprint? What happened there? The issue I remember seeing had these dark, moody colors. The colors in the reprint—what a bright, shiny, happy comic about Russian Roulette. “It’s the feel good Russian Roulette comic book of the year.” Is that how it looked when it was originally printed? Maybe I'm so used to seeing the old, worn-out, grey, torn-up copies that I never imagined what it looked like when it was brand new. Same exact thing happens when I look at your mom, naked. When she's having sex with Don Ameche's ghost. Dammit. Goddammit. Oh, I shouldn't have even tried; couldn't let it go. Goddammit, I really thought I could save the whole Don Ameche thing, in the eleventh hour, and it's just-- where's the goddamn Cocoon when you need it? Don Ameche Joke Cocoon, you have failed me for the last time!! This started out so earnestly, with the crucifix and the Jesus and the spirals, and ... What happened, Internet? If only keyboards came with delete keys...

Wait, What? Episode 5.1: Ultimate Expectations Are Better Than Great Ones, Apparently...

Just in time for the long weekend, Graeme and I roll out the first installment of Wait, What? Episode 5.1. While we'll probably record something to thrash out the whole Disney/Marvel situation, Episode 5 of Wait, What? was recorded the day before, so you're free from idle speculation about the state of Howard The Duck's pants (for now). Instead, Graeme and I talk about Blackest Night #2, what the hell is up with the Spectre, Ultimate Comics Spider-Man #1, Ultimate Avengers #1 (or whatever the hell it's called), that weirdo John Byrne Millennium crossover issue and much, much more.

Thanks for listening!

Arriving 9/2/2009

So, Disney buying Marvel, eh? Yeah, that's likely to be a game-changer.

No real commentary from me today on that, however -- Ben broke his arm yesterday, so I lost most of the day to the Emergency Room (and, let me tell you, if you have an injured kid in San Francisco, you'd be REALLY smart to take them to the new Pediatric Emergency Room at California Pacific Medical Center on California St., because those people were AWESOME, 100% kid-oriented [They have a staffer JUST to explain procedures to kids in kid-language!], astonishingly professional, and we didn't have that wait-to-entry that I normally associate with ERs -- we had a doctor to see in like 15 minutes. I'd never call going to an ER "pleasant", but that was pretty darn close!), and I've got to finish the order form to boot (plus, huh, first of the month tomorrow, got to pay some bills before I go today...) -- I'll think more about that tomorrow and Wednesday...

Anyway, sold looking week o' comical goodness...

AGENTS OF ATLAS #10
AUTHORITY #14
BATMAN #690
BATMAN CONFIDENTIAL #33
BETTY & VERONICA DIGEST #197
BLACK PANTHER 2 #8
BOYS #34
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER #28 CHEN CVR
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER #28 JEANTY CVR
CABLE #18
CARS RADIATOR SPRINGS #1
CHEW #4
CURSED PIRATE GIRL #2 (OF 3)
DARING MYSTERY COMICS #1 70TH ANNIV SPECIAL
DEAD RUN #4
DEADPOOL #15
DO ANDROIDS DREAM OF ELECTRIC SHEEP #3 (OF 24)
EXILES #6
FALL OUT TOY WORKS #1 (OF 5)
FINAL CRISIS AFTERMATH RUN #5 (OF 6)
FROM THE ASHES #4
GHOST RIDERS HEAVENS ON FIRE #2 (OF 6)
GREEK STREET #3
GRIMJACK MANX CAT #2
HERCULES KNIVES OF KUSH #2 (OF 5) A CVR MARKO
HOTWIRE #4 (OF 4) A CVR PUGH
HOUSE OF M MASTERS OF EVIL #2 (OF 4)
IMMORTAL WEAPONS #2 (OF 5)
INCOGNITO #6
INVINCIBLE IRON MAN #17
IRON MAN ARMOR WARS #2 (OF 4)
IRREDEEMABLE #6
JERSEY GODS #7
JONAH HEX #47
JUSTICE LEAGUE CRY FOR JUSTICE #3 (OF 7)
LAST RESORT #2
LOONEY TUNES #178
LUKE CAGE NOIR #2 (OF 4)
MAGOG #1
MARVEL ZOMBIES RETURN #1
MICE TEMPLAR DESTINY #3
MIGHTY #8
MYSTIC COMICS #1 70TH ANNIV SPECIAL
NORTH 40 #3 (OF 6)
NORTHLANDERS #20
OFFICIAL INDEX TO MARVEL UNIVERSE #9
RAWBONE #4 (OF 4)
RED TORNADO #1 (OF 6)
RESURRECTION VOL 2 #3
ROBERT E HOWARD THULSA DOOM #1
SAVAGE DRAGON #152
SCOURGE OF GODS FALL #3 (OF 3)
SOLOMON GRUNDY #7 (OF 7) (BLACKEST NIGHT)
STAR WARS INVASION #3 (OF 5)
STARR THE SLAYER #1 (OF 4)
STRANGE ADVENTURES #7 (OF 8)
STRANGE TALES #1 (OF 3)
SUPERGIRL ANNUAL #1
SWEET TOOTH #1
THE GOOD THE BAD & THE UGLY #3
TORCH #1 (OF 8)
ULTIMATE COMICS SPIDER-MAN #2
VERONICA #196
WEDNESDAY COMICS #9 (OF 12)
WITCHFINDER IN THE SERVICE OF ANGELS #3 (OF 5)
YOUNG LIARS #18

Books / Mags / Stuff
ABSOLUTE V FOR VENDETTA HC
AMULET SC VOL 02 STONEKEEPERS CURSE
ANGEL BLOOD AND TRENCHES TP VOL 01
BATMAN GOTHAM AFTER MIDNIGHT TP
BLEACH TP VOL 28
CLASSIC MARVEL FIGURINE COLL MAG #101 WAR MACHINE
CSI INTERNS GN VOL 01 (OF 2)
DC LIBRARY JLA BY GEORGE PEREZ HC VOL 01
DC SUPERHERO FIGURINE COLL MAG #18 M MANHUNTER
DC SUPERHERO FIGURINE COLL MAG #19 NIGHTWING
DC SUPERHERO FIGURINE COLL MAG #34 BLUE BEETLE
DC SUPERHERO FIGURINE COLL MAG #35 BIZARRO
DEAD IRONS HC
DMZ TP VOL 07 WAR POWERS
ESSENTIAL SUB-MARINER TP VOL 01
FOODBOY GN (OCT032442)
GI JOE ORIGINS TP VOL 01
GROWN UPS ARE DUMB NO OFFENSE SC
HONEY LICKERS SORORITY GN VOL 02 (A)
HULK GRAY PREM HC
INCREDIBLES FAMILY MATTERS TP
JSA HC VOL 05 BLACK ADAM AND ISIS
LORDS OF MISRULE HC
MARVEL SUPER HERO SQUAD TP HERO UP DIGEST HERO CVR
MARVEL ZOMBIES ARMY OF DARKNESS TP
NOCTURNALS HC VOL 02 DARK FOREVER AND OTHER TALES PX ED
NOCTURNALS HC VOL 02 DARK FOREVER AND OTHER TALES REG ED
PROCESS RECESS HC VOL 03 HALLOWED SEAM
REBEL GN
SAVAGE SWORD OF CONAN TP VOL 06
SILENT MOBIUS COMPLETE ED GN VOL 01
SPY VS SPY TP DANGER INTRIGUE STUPIDITY
SPY VS SPY TP MASTERS OF MAYHEM
SPY VS SPY TP MISSIONS OF MADNESS
STAR TREK ARCHIVES TP VOL 06 BEST OF ALTERNATE UNIVERSES
SUPERMAN NEW KRYPTON HC VOL 02
WOLVERINE AND POWER PACK TP WILD PACK DIGEST
WONDERFUL WIZARD OZ HC
ZOMNIBUS GN VOL 01

What looks good to YOU?

-B

Claremont's X-Men 2: How John Byrne Changed The World

More Claremont retrospective! This time, the first two years of the Byrne run, wherein everything comes together remarkably quickly, and I compare John Byrne to Joe Sinnott. Or something.

Ignoring the fill-in in UNCANNY X-MEN #106 (Although: Chris Claremont and Bill Mantlo together! There should've been much more of this), #107 starts off Claremont's third year on the title with an important milestone: The last issue before it truly becomes the X-Men we recognize. Oh, so many things are almost there, but it's as if Dave Cockrum was holding Claremont back from achieving full Claremont or something; as soon as John Byrne and Terry Austen appear in #108, everything clicks into place: The characters' speech patterns, the "giving your life force to save existence" soon-to-be-cliche makes its first appearance (including Storm saying "It is my life to give, my friend" by way of explanation), the overly elaborate soap opera - space pirate and furry Corsair is Cyclops' dad?!? - the book just suddenly becomes the X-Men through some unexplainable magic, much in the same way that Lee and Kirby's Fantastic Four suddenly makes sense when Joe Sinnott starts inking Kirby in the late #40s. By the end of that third year, Claremont has already worked in his first psychic mind-rape.

(It's possible that one of the reasons that the early Claremont/Byrne issues seems like the book makes this leap into a more pure X-Men-ness is because that run has become the touchstone for most fans, and subsequent creators, as the "best" X-Men run ever, but it's more than that; Claremont's writing suddenly becomes much clearer and more focused when Byrne appears. I don't know if there was an obvious reason behind the scenes - The editor's still Archie Goodwin throughout, so it's not that...? - but the shift is noticable and somewhat odd, when reading the issues in quick succession.)

By the book's fourth year, it's made it to monthly status in time to really start working out the kinks; oddly enough, the fourth year feels very much like the first two, in that Claremont revisits old X-Men villains and stories (Magneto, Sauron, the Savage Land, Sunfire), but at the same time, you can tell that he's also more in control of the characters and the plot than he was previously - Magneto's appearance pays off months of foreshadowing by showing Cyclops' fears about the new team "not being ready" and getting their asses handed to them, for example, leading to the first period (of many, it becomes a favored Claremont trick when he wants to switch things up) where the world believes they're dead, which allows him to show Scott and Jean outside of their relationship for pretty much the first time in their history. Unlike before, where it felt as if Claremont was using old characters and ideas because he didn't know what else to do, this time it feels as if he's comfortable and knows what he's up to.

The confidence is matched by Byrne and Austen's incredibly slick visuals. I mean that as much as an insult as a compliment, I have to admit; as revered as the art in these issues is - and as good as it is, as well - it really is very much eye candy, and at times overly glossy and soulless. Byrne's women, in particular, are almost distractingly... I don't know what the word is... vapid? glamorous, in a bad way? generic? They lack personality, despite what Claremont puts in their mouths (Now, that doesn't sound right), and occasionally the art feels so... professional, and impersonal, and "perfect," that it pulls me out of the experience and leaves me cold. Am I alone in that?

The comfort and confidence - and newfound success and acclaim - were making Claremont and Byrne more bold, though; by the end of the fourth year of Claremont's run on the book, he'd put the team back together with one exception... and that's because he was already at work laying the groundwork for the Dark Phoenix storyline, which would change superhero comics - and Uncanny X-Men in particular - in ways that he couldn't even have imagined.

Malthusian Superheroics: Chris reviews JUSTICE SOCIETY OF AMERICA

Fellow Savage David Uzumeri is at the Toronto Fan Expo and he's liveblogging Marvel and DC's panels. Friday's DC panel featured a discussion of recap pages, with Len Wein positing that "we used to work under the theory, which I don't think is true anymore, that every issue is somebody's first issue" and Didio affirming his anti-recap-page position. Earlier this year Didio said he thought "the writers should be able to introduce readers to the ongoing story within the issue itself."

Let's take a look at that then, shall we?

Bill Willingham, Matthew Sturges and Jesus Merino started a run last month in JUSTICE SOCIETY OF AMERICA #29. JSA is a book with a sprawling cast of legacy heroes a concept Willingham and Sturges embrace, keeping nearly all of former writer Geoff Johns's bloated team around for their first issue. There are thirteen Society members on the cover, fifteen on the opening page, and by the end of the first sequence twenty one members total, including two introduced in this issue. Soon, the team follows a distress beacon and are ambushed by a mysterious team of twenty one villains, who appear to be part of the "Global Ultra Society of Dread" and have "trained themselves to take on specific members of the JSA."

Fortunately, no JSAer attempts to fight someone not specifically trained for them, and the GUSoD correctly guessed which of the Society's two dozen members would show up for the fight. Meanwhile, one of the new members sneaks up on Mr. Terrific, stabbing him repeatedly in the back for some reason.

Taken as the twenty ninth (or really, the one hundred and somethingteenth, given the previous JSA series and recent annuals and Kingdom Come one-shots) issue, this book borders on coherent. A less charitable person would question why Willingham and Sturges open their run by apparently killing the Society's most prominent black member while writing out Jakeem Thunder and Amazing Man. One might also question why they turned Obsidian, the team's only LGBT member, into an inanimate black egg. But that isn't my primary concern.

Where this book utterly fails is accessiblity to that fabled reader for whom this is their first issue. Sturges and Willingham have a sizable following from their work on Vertigo's Fables family of titles, and this issue was heralded as a "New Era." It stands to follow that JSA #29 is designed to be a jumping-on point for Fables fans and curious readers alike. And yet, the first issue is crammed full of forty characters, over half of which are never identified by name.

It's one thing not to name cannon fodder villains, though by implying each one was handpicked to counteract a Society member should make them more significant. Even as a dedicated superhero nerd, I can't identify many of them, and my list of characters in this comic includes such luminaries as "Metal Dude from Flash(?)", "Luchador Guy" and "Extreme Legolas".

Even more crucially, half of the Society members aren't identified. Stargirl, one of the only characters with a plot throughline besides "stand around then get ambushed" is repeatedly addressed by friend and foe alike, but "Stargirl" -- or even "Courtney", her government name -- appear nowhere in JSA #29. Power Girl, Society chairperson and star of a new ongoing series, isn't named either. She gets two lines: "What's wrong, Alan?" and "Bring it, cupcake!"

This week's JSA #30 somewhat addresses this issue by having people refer to Stargirl by name, and someone appeals to "Pee Gee" as their leader, though the context of the panels makes it so that it appears as if "Pee Gee" is a pet name for Alan Scott. If DC's comments about being concerned about things reading better in the trade, it's possible by the end of these six issues, every JSA member will be named, and perhaps even given a distinguishing characteristic.

In this week's issue, the Global Ultra Society of Dread is dispatched with the help of Doctor Fate, who one can infer is a new Dr. Fate, I guess? I either missed or blocked out the story that introduced this new Fate, but I can only assume there's a good reason Willingham and Sturges introduced a twenty-second member to the team in this issue.

I know that this sort of questioning can be intellectually dishonest, and I don't know how much a recap page crammed with dozens of headshots and names could've helped. But at least it would allow people to Google the names of the characters. Even as a longtime DCU follower, this book is AWFUL to try and follow.

I can only imagine what some poor soul brought in by Willingham and Sturges's names must be going through.

 

Wedding Belles

ARCHIE #600: It has been a really long time since I've last read an issue of ARCHIE. Well, a proper one, at least -- I glanced through one of those "new look" issues, but threw it across the room in disgust.

So I was a little surprised as to just how much I enjoyed this first part of "Archie Marries Veronica"

Some people, I guess, might object to this being an "Elseworlds" (Archie walks one night along "Memory Lane", but decides to walk UP the path), but it seems to me that the Archie line depends on being essentially changeless (If slightly out of tune with what teems are really like), but, at the same time, moving away from that eternal formula can seemingly yield fairly alright stories.

So, yeah, it's a little strange to see Archie Andrews as a drifting post-collegial young man who makes the decision to change the way he's done thing all of these years and to make a commitment to Ronnie, but it also worked in a very strange way.

I mean, I'm certainly a "Betty Man", and that makes a lot more sense to me than Veronica, but Mike Uslan's script here is remarkably crisp, as well as filled with real drama and pathos.

I have a slightly bigger problem with the art -- I guess my eye just has a hard time with any drawing that's NOT Dan DeCarlo, but Stan Goldberg has been drawing Archie for years (Decades?), so it isn't like this looks "off model" or something. BUT...

... they made a really strange choice to not actually render most of the female character's noses in most panels.

It just looks wrong, especially on Veronica.

In fact there are several panels that, if I looked at them out of context, without a picture of Archie or Jughead, I don't know that I would necessarily have guessed it was from an Archie comic.

Not a major deal, either way, but it has knocked down my grade just a little. What's surprising to me is even with that knock, I'm still going to say this issue was VERY GOOD. Wow! Whudathunkit?

What did YOU think?

-B

Arriving 8/26/2009

Yay, Ben's first day of First Grade! You'll forgive me if I'm distracted...

Big ole week of excellent comics this time through...

28 DAYS LATER #1
ANITA BLAKE LC NECROMANCER #4 (OF 5)
AVENGERS INITIATIVE #27
BAD KIDS GO TO HELL #3 (OF 4)
BARACK THE BARBARIAN #2 (OF 4)
BART SIMPSON COMICS #49
BATMAN AND ROBIN #3
BATMAN THE BRAVE AND THE BOLD #8
BATMAN WIDENING GYRE #1 (OF 6)
BETA RAY BILL GODHUNTER #3 (OF 3)
BETTY & VERONICA #243
BILLY BATSON AND THE MAGIC OF SHAZAM #7
BLACKEST NIGHT TITANS #1 (OF 3)
BONEYARD #28 (OF 28) (RES)
BOYS HEROGASM #4 (OF 6)
BUCK ROGERS #3
CAPTAIN ACTION COMICS #5 GULACY RETRO CVR
CEREBUS ARCHIVE #3
CITIZEN REX #2 (OF 6)
DARK AVENGERS #8 DAX
DARK REIGN ELEKTRA #5 (OF 5) DKR
DARK REIGN SINISTER SPIDER-MAN #3 (OF 4) DKR
DARK TOWER THE FALL OF GILEAD #4 (OF 6)
DARK WOLVERINE #77 DKR
DARK X-MEN BEGINNING #3 (OF 3) DAX
DARKNESS PITT #1 KEOWN CVR A
DEADPOOL #14
DETECTIVE COMICS #856
DOCTOR WHO COLD-BLOODED WAR (ONE SHOT)
DYNAMO 5 #24
FANTASTIC FOUR #570
FINAL CRISIS AFTERMATH INK #4 (OF 6)
FLASH REBIRTH #4 (OF 6)
FRANK FRAZETTAS SORCERER FRAZETTA CVR A (ONE SHOT)
GOTHAM CITY SIRENS #3
GREEN LANTERN #45 (BLACKEST NIGHT)
GRIMM FAIRY TALES #41 CVR A CAMPBELL
GUARDIANS OF GALAXY #17
HALO HELLJUMPER #2 (OF 5)
HULK #14
I AM LEGION #5 (OF 6)
INCREDIBLE HERCULES #133
INCREDIBLE HULK #601
INCREDIBLES #0
JUGHEADS DOUBLE DIGEST #153
JUSTICE SOCIETY OF AMERICA #30
KILLAPALOOZA #4 (OF 6)
KING CITY #1
LAST DAYS OF ANIMAL MAN #4 (OF 6)
MADAME XANADU #14
MARVEL ADVENTURES SPIDER-MAN #54
MS MARVEL #44 DKR
MUPPET SHOW TREASURE OF PEG LEG WILSON #2 (OF 4)
NEW AVENGERS #56 DKR
NEW MUTANTS #4
NOVA #28
PHANTOM GENERATIONS #4
PREDATOR #2 (OF 4)
PROJECT SUPERPOWERS CHAPTER TWO #2
RED CIRCLE THE SHIELD #1
RED SONJA #47
REX MUNDI DH ED #19 (OF 19)
RIFTWAR #3 (OF 5)
RUNAWAYS 3 #13
SCALPED #31
SECRET WARRIORS #7
SHERLOCK HOLMES #4 (OF 5)
SKRULL KILL KREW #4 (OF 5) DKR
SON OF HULK #14
SONIC UNIVERSE #7
SPIN ANGELS #1 Of(3)
STAR WARS DARK TIMES #14 BLUE HARVEST PT 2 (OF 5)
STAR WARS LEGACY #39 TATOOINE PT 3 (OF 4)
STREET FIGHTER LEGENDS CHUN LI #4 (OF 4) A CVR DOGAN
SUPERMAN #691
SUPERMANS PAL JIMMY OLSEN SPECIAL #2
TEEN TITANS #74
TIMESTORM 2009 2099 #4 (OF 4)
UNKNOWN #4 (OF 4)
UNKNOWN SOLDIER #11
USAGI YOJIMBO #122
WEDNESDAY COMICS #8 (OF 12)
WILDCATS #14
WOLVERINE FIRST CLASS #18
WOLVERINE ORIGINS #39
WONDER WOMAN #35
X-FORCE #18
X-FORCE #18 70TH FRAME VAR
X-MEN FOREVER #6
ZERO KILLER #4 (OF 6) (RES)

Books / Mags / Stuff
AUTHORITY WORLDS END TP BOOK 01
BORDERLINE TP VOL 03
CABLE TP VOL 02 WAITING FOR THE END OF THE WORLD
GHOST RIDER TRIALS AND TRIBULATIONS TP
IMMORTAL IRON FIST PREM HC VOL 05 ESCAPE FROM EIGHTH CITY
LANTERN CORPS BLACK SYMBOL T/S LG (O/A)
LANTERN CORPS BLACK SYMBOL T/S XL (O/A)
MUPPET SHOW TP
OLD MAN WINTER & OTHER SORDID TALES GN
PREVIEWS #252 SEPTEMBER 2009 (NET)
REIGN IN HELL TP
SECRET SATURDAYS GN VOL 01
SECRET SIX UNHINGED TP
SHOWCASE PRESENTS ECLIPSO TP
SPARROW HC VOL 12 SERGIO TOPPI
TOMARTS ACTION FIGURE DIGEST #179/#180
TOON TREASURY OF CLASSIC CHILDRENS COMICS HC
TRINITY TP VOL 02
ULTIMATE X-MEN ULTIMATE COLLECTION TP VOL 03
UNCANNY X-MEN SISTERHOOD TP
WIZARD MAGAZINE #216 TRAVIS CHAREST CAPT AMERICA CVR (C: 0-1
WORLD OF WARCRAFT TP VOL 01
X-FORCE CABLE MESSIAH WAR HC
X-FORCE TP VOL 02 OLD GHOSTS

What looks good to YOU?

-B

Claremont's X-Men 1: Before They Wuz Fab

The first couple of years of Chris Claremont's UNCANNY X-MEN (#94-105 - the book was bi-monthly back then) are really weird to look back on, knowing what came later: Len Wein had introduced the All-New, All-Different team in Giant Size X-Men without Claremont's involvement, and so the first couple of years feels like the writer trying to work out what to do with the characters.

There's no real singular voice to the series, at this early point, probably because Claremont himself hadn't really worked out what we'd later come to recognize as his voice; instead, everything reads pretty much like the generic late '70s Marvel comic book that is was - Free of the expectations of what an X-Men comic should be, Claremont and Dave Cockrum pursue their own interests (space opera!), bring in characters from other books (And when you're bringing in supporting characters from The Hulk, you've got to know that you're desperate) and pick at tidbits from the original incarnation of the book, just to keep that sense of continuity going.

It's enjoyably free of the oppressive angst that the books went on to develop, the consistent sense of persecution and fear and loss that defined the franchise after the Phoenix arc, but it's also... pretty bland stuff, really. If the characters hadn't gone on to bigger and better things, there'd be nothing to really differentiate this from Marvel Team-Up or The Defenders or whatever. As it is, it's mostly worthwhile to see Claremont slowly realizing who each character was, in fits and starts (Storm's sudden claustrophobia which affects her when she's in a castle in #102, but not when she's in a sealed military base within a mountain in #95, because he hadn't thought of it, back then; or Wolverine's claws being revealed to be part of him in #98 and the way it seems to crystalize the character so that he finally feels like the Wolverine we know by #100), and also what kind of story worked for them.

There's a free-wheeling, unrestrained feeling to the series here that it lost somewhere in the mid #100s and never regained, sadly enough, but one of the side-effects of that is that there's also no real sense of weight or importance to anything, either; the closest you get is Jean Grey's transformation into Phoenix, but even that has a familiar, never-ending Mighty Marvel Soap Opera feel to it that doesn't turn into what we know it as now until much later. For now, though, these issues are Okay, but nothing more, unless you know what comes later.

While We Wait For Me To Get My Act Together...

Not an official review post - Those're coming later this week, now that I've finished writing Ono for this month - but if you're looking for some Hot Comic Reviewin' Action, go check out Chad Nevett's heroic 24-hour Blogathon effort from yesterday/this morning, taking a look at Bendis' Avengers and surrounding books. I don't always agree - and in some cases, very much disagree, with what he says, but it's well worth checking out.

This Isn't The End, Beautiful Friend...

I realized, while reading the most recent issue of THE UNWRITTEN, what it is I miss about Y: The Last Man: Endings. I'm not talking about Brian K. Vaughan's almost unparalleled skill at managing to close each issue with a cliffhanger that was guaranteed to bring you back next month - although, really, that was something to see, and be jealous of - but instead, the idea that each trade collection would have some kind of ending, even as it continued the over-arcing story.

(For those who get concerned, yes, this continues after the jump.)

I've been enjoying The Unwritten in my own quiet way these past few months. Yes, it's not as smart as it thinks it is or really wants to be, and yes, the Harry Potter analogs are a little too unsubtle perhaps, but it's a fun book and there's something interesting to me in the greater story that it admittedly seems a little too content to hint at instead of actually, you know, explore (If I was reviewing it properly, I'd probably go with Okay; it's not wowed me at any point, but it's an entertaining, if occasionally frustratingly slow, ride so far). But the latest issue, #4, ended on such a sour note for me that I found myself thinking the kind of meta- thoughts that never go anywhere good.

What bothered me so much was that the last page of the story identifies itself as "Tommy Taylor and the Bogus Identity - Conclusion" despite the fact that nothing in the story had actually come to any conclusion. It's not even as if the story had come to a clear act close or anything, either; there was nothing particularly final about the issue, or anything to differentiate it from any other issue (Other than a sudden lurch toward slasher movie-dom, but that's not necessarily a good thing)... It clearly just meant that this would be the end of the first trade paperback, an arbitrary breaking point without much meaning.

And, thinking about it, I realized that Unwritten wasn't the only series that suffered from this problem. As much as I like it - and I really do - Matt Sturges' House of Mystery doesn't do story-arcs as much as just continuing on with the same uber-plot surrounding each issue's one-off, and in that title, too, the titles of story-arcs denote future collections instead of any sense of beginning, middle, end. Air, too, tells one larger story without break, leading to an ending to the first collection that seems as much like they ran out of paper as a planned break point.

I'm not sure how I feel about this, or who to blame (If there's blame to be given); I like stories with long-term goals, after all, and there's something to be said for being able to tell one, massive, story over a number of years. But there's also something to be said for being more aware of, and writing towards, the formats your story is appearing in, and part of that (I feel) is making the collections of individual issues have more... consequence? point? shape? than these series currently have. Vertigo as a line has gained a lot from trade collections, and it's been commented more than once that the TP format is the stories' true home. If that's true, it'd be nice if the books themselves reflected that thinking, and treated their collections with more respect every now and again.

We're #1!

ULTIMATE COMICS AVENGERS #1: Well, not that you'd know that was the title by looking AT the title, which, can I say? drives me bucking fonkers. Indicia really should match title, sigh.

(And, they're not really "Avengers", either -- that word doesn't appear to be uttered within the comic whatsoever, but whatever!)

For action and sardonic wit, this picks up smoothly from Millar's last ULTIMATES run, though I'd've been happier if it appeared that either Millar or Bendis even READ "Ultimatum", because Millar has it here as "New York flooded", which is a smidge different than "millions dead as New York is decimated by a tsunami", but, again, whatever...

As a retailer, I'm dismayed that both this and UCSM #1 shipped the same week (And in one of the single biggest ship weeks of the year, at that) -- and first week sales seem to match that dismay. Both are well under the sell-through for U3 #5, or USM #133 in their first week, which leads me to perhaps rashly conclude that this reboot has chased away more of the audience than it has drawn in.

Either way, I thought this first issue was perfectly OK

ULTIMATE COMICS SPIDER-MAN #1: I have to say that I find the notion that within six months New York City is COMPLETELY RESTORED to be far more "comic booky" than if, say, Wolverine had already returned from the (what appeared to be pretty final) Dead. I mean, fuck, here we are EIGHT YEARS after 9/11, and we still don't have anything at Ground Zero, and that was TWO buildings. Between that and the "Hey, maybe Spidey is dead, too? HA! PSYCHE!" bullshit, my interest in this comic has nearly completely cratered.

USM used to be one of the "top read" comics in my weekly pile -- I'd want to get to it ASAP, but now I'm not sure if I really care to read another page.

Part of this, I think, stems from the dissonance of "Oh, look, Peter's a loser, he's working at BK", then a few pages later he's being praised by the police (what? Peter never read the Bugle?) and making out with a hot chick. I don't know, this feels like a moment that passed, and the fact that this is a relaunched #1, instead of being #134 only increases that feeling for me.

I could barely muster a half-hearted, EH, sorry.

ADVENTURE COMICS #1 (or #504, depending): Hurm, I dunno -- I don't find Conner to be that compelling of a character in the first place, though I guess that maybe that last panel reveal might go somewhere halfway interesting. But I kind of doubt it. The art was pretty, however. A mild OK for the lead story.

I disliked the back-up, though -- I'm of the camp that says that the Legion isn't even remotely interesting out of their future milieu; and this Starman story line really needed to end about a year ago. And the "coming up in.." section that Geoff used so well previously falls utterly flat here -- none of those six "pre-hangers" particularly interest me. I'm going to go with AWFUL for the back half. Averaging out as an EH on the issue.

THE MARVELS PROJECT #1: Brubaker and Epting are a great team, who know how to make great comics, but this whole thing felt a bit weightless to me. I guess it is noce to have some of the back story of the 1940s Marvel U fleshed out, but I can't say convincingly that I actually cared about any of the revelations. Strongly OK, but nothing more than that...

What did YOU think?

-B

Wait, What? ep. 4.4: Just When You Think We're Dead...

Our final installment of the week's podcast is almost an hour long and has it all: Tyrese Gibson's Mayhem!, Captain America Reborn #2, Cracker, Godzilla, Aquaman...then just as it seems we're winding down, a dose of meta and Graeme breaking out the old-school knowledge and talking Chris Claremont's original run of X-Men. Oh, and Julie & Julia, of course.

Oh, and if you get a chance, please take a moment to tell Graeme in the comments he's a dreamboat--it'll make my mancrush seems a little less unseemly...(or will it?)

Again, our thanks to everyone who's chimed in with comments and suggestions, and thanks to Trent Reznor, whose Creative Commons license allows us to use the most excellent Track 18 from his ambient album Ghosts I-IV as our intro and outro music. Thanks for listening!

Arriving 8/19/2009

OF COURSE, after last week's brutal onslaught of a billion titles, here's a teeny tiny week of books. *sigh*

A G SUPER EROTIC ANTHOLOGY #107 (A)
AIR #12
AMAZING SPIDER-MAN #603
AOD ASH SAVES OBAMA #1 (OF 4)
ARCHIE #600
ASTOUNDING WOLF-MAN #18
ATOMIC ROBO SHADOW FROM BEYOND TIME #4 (OF 5)
BATGIRL #1
BATMAN STREETS OF GOTHAM #3
BLACKEST NIGHT SUPERMAN #1 (OF 3)
BRAVE AND THE BOLD #26
CONAN THE CIMMERIAN #13
DAREDEVIL #500
DARK REIGN HOOD #4 (OF 5) DKR
DARK REIGN MISTER NEGATIVE #3 (OF 3) DKR
DAYS MISSING #1 (OF 5) DALE KEOWN CVR
DEADPOOL SUICIDE KINGS #5 (OF 5)
DOCTOR WHO ONGOING #2
DOKTOR SLEEPLESS #13 (RES)
EX MACHINA #44
FARSCAPE GONE & BACK #2
FINAL CRISIS AFTERMATH DANCE #4 (OF 6)
GENEXT UNITED #4 (OF 5)
GRAVEL #13
HELLBLAZER #258
INVINCIBLE #65
JACK OF FABLES #37
JUSTICE LEAGUE OF AMERICA #36
MARVEL ADVENTURES AVENGERS #39
MIGHTY AVENGERS #28
MONSTERS INC LAUGH FACTORY #1
OUTSIDERS #21
PALS N GALS DOUBLE DIGEST #134
POE (BOOM) #2
POWER GIRL #4
PROJECT SUPERPOWERS MEET THE BAD GUYS #1
PUNISHER #8
PUNISHER FRANK CASTLE MAX #73
PUNISHER NOIR #1 (OF 4)
RED CIRCLE THE WEB #1
ROBERT JORDANS NEW SPRING #7 (RES)
SIMPSONS COMICS #157
STAND AMERICAN NIGHTMARES #5 (OF 5)
STAR TREK SPOCK REFLECTIONS #2
STAR WARS KNIGHTS OLD REPUBLIC #44 REAPING PT 2 (OF 2)
STARCRAFT #3
SUPER FRIENDS #18
SUPERGIRL #44
SUPERMAN ANNUAL #14
SUPERMAN BATMAN #63
SWORDSMITH ASSASSIN #1
TINY TITANS #19
UNTHINKABLE #4 (OF 5)
VIGILANTE #9
VIKING #3
WE KILL MONSTERS #2 (OF 6)
WEDNESDAY COMICS #7 (OF 12)
WITCHBLADE #129 SEJIC CVR A
WOLVERINE WEAPON X #4
WORLD OF WARCRAFT #22
X-FACTOR #47
X-MEN LEGACY #227 DAX
ZORRO #15

Books / Mags / Stuff
A D NEW ORLEANS AFTER DELUGE GN
ASTONISHING X-MEN PREM HC GHOST BOX
AVENGERS FOREVER HC
BEST EROTIC COMICS 2009 SC (A)
BRAVE AND THE BOLD THE BOOK OF DESTINY TP
DARK AVENGERS PREM HC VOL 01 ASSEMBLE
DARK ENTRIES HC
ESSENTIAL MARVEL TEAM-UP TP VOL 03
FILTHY RICH HC
HEXED HC
JUDGE DREDD MEGAZINE #287
JUXTAPOZ VOL 16 #9 SEP 2009
LEES TOY REVIEW #201 AUG 2009
LITTLE FLUFFY GIGOLO PELU TP VOL 01 (A)
NAOKI URASAWA 20TH CENTURY BOYS GN VOL 04
NEW AVENGERS PREM HC VOL 11 SEARCH FOR SORCERER SUPREME
NYX TP NO WAY HOME
PUNISHER FRANK CASTLE MAX TP SIX HOURS TO KILL
SHRAPNEL TP ARISTEIA RISING
SPIDER-MAN MARY JANE TP YOU JUST HIT THE JACKPOT
SQUADRON SUPREME TP BRIGHT SHINING LIES
UBU BUBU TP VOL 01 FILTH
UNKNOWN SOLDIER TP VOL 01 HAUNTED HOUSE
VADEBONCOEUR COLLECTION OF IMAGES #11
WET MOON GN VOL 05
WHEN WE FALL GN

What looks good to YOU?

-B

My brother the ape: Douglas reads some 8/11 periodicals

MARVEL ADVENTURES SUPER HEROES #14: No grade on this one--I feel a little hinky about grading comics written by my neighbors (Paul Tobin, in this case)--but I will say that I enjoyed this issue immensely and wanted to call it to people's attention. It's a Hawkeye/Blonde Phantom team-up (what are the odds of two Blonde Phantom stories coming out in the same month?), a done-in-one detective story with a couple of action set-pieces and a lot of lively banter. It earns its "all ages" stamp: it's a very 10-year-old-friendly funnybook, but it's got a bunch of Easter eggs for people who've read a billion Marvel comics already, including a cute "Civil War" riff and, actually, the fact that it's got the Blonde Phantom in it in the first place. It's also driven by the longstanding friendship of two characters who may not even have appeared on panel together before, and it's pretty convincing on that front. DOMINIC FORTUNE #1: Yeah, it's a Howard Chaykin comic, all right: aerial dogfight on page 1, Jews in tuxes on page 5, anti-Semites in tuxes on page 6, blowjob on page 9. GOOD.

RED HERRING #1: First issue of a David Tischman/Philip Bond/David Hahn miniseries for which I've seen virtually no advance press; that may have something to do with the fact that I've read the first issue a few times and still couldn't tell you quite what it's about. It's overloaded with ideas, some of them pretty good, but none of them given enough room to breathe. There's a bunch of X-Files pastiche (particularly an alien-corpse-in-1951 flashback that leads nowhere in particular), a little cheesecake, some ridiculous name-based gags (the protagonists are Red Herring and Maggie MacGuffin, and other characters include Meyer Weiner and--this is a bad one--Afi Komen), some nasty violence, etc. There's iffy second-person narration for a lot of the story that disappears, then gets awkwardly replaced by third-person omniscient narration. Bond's art is really effective, as always: his characters usually have a sort of bobblehead look, with slightly oversized heads, but that gives him & Hahn more real estate for the facial expressions that are their strongest point as a team. OKAY.

WEDNESDAY COMICS #6: Halfway through the series, and I'm surprised by what's working and what isn't. The most welcome surprise is Karl Kerschl and Brenden Fletcher's Flash, which is taking advantage of the Sunday-page format in increasingly clever ways; the most unexpected misfire is Gaiman and Allred's Metamorpho, whose formal play not only doesn't serve its story very well but is keeping the story from happening much at all. In any case, I find myself looking repeatedly and with delight at almost every page of this series--I have to adjust my gaze for Ben Caldwell's crammed Wonder Woman (the vertical layout this week slowed me down even more), but so what? I would buy a $4 Sunday newspaper whose only comic strip was Ryan Sook's Kamandi. VERY GOOD.

Tilting at Windmills #183 is up!

People were asking me to follow up on the "why retailer's conservatism hurts" bit from a month or two back, so here we go. Go read the column on CBR!

Also, in the follow-up category, Percy Carey has quit as Marketing Director of Tyrese Gibson's Mayhem! in part due to the stuff I discussed in last months column. You can read Carey's press release here.

-B

Wait, What? Ep. 4.3: Why Geoff Johns Isn't As Bad As You Think

Yep, the very next installment, right here already. We talk about Blackest Night, Superboy Prime, Amazing Spider-Man, and I think I finally end up making a point somehow. Long-time listeners (since, say, Wednesday) will feel rewarded. Also, extra-special this time around: annotations! You can find Laura Hudson's terrific interview with Johns about Blackest Night at Comics Alliance here, and my 2005 FBR riff on DC crossover events here on our site. (Some of it reads almost prescient, in an ultra-smartass kind of way).

Ep. 4.4 is right around the corner! (By which I mean, probably first thing Monday?) Until then, have a great weekend and enjoy the 'cast!

Wait, What? ep. 4.2: Hey, You Asked...

I think our only regret about this installment of Wait, What is that we didn't get to answer everyone's questions--but we did our scattershot best. If you ask me, this one's worth a listen just to hear us respond to the "Crying Superheroes--Threat or Menace?" question.

Hope you enjoy! 4.3 will go up tomorrow (barring catastrophe) and will talk about Blackest Night. Oh, yes.