"...are you experienced?"
San Francisco's Premiere Comic Book Shop

Choose from the pulldown menu:

If you've come to this page from a link outside our pages,
or if you've never read our intro to the Savage Critic,
please do so here. (It'll help prepare you!)

The Savage Critic: December 11th 2002
By Brian Hibbs and Jeff Lester

Welcome back, my friends, to the show that never ends.

Blechy and horrible weather in San Francisco today – everyone is hiding at home scared of the rain.

I’m sitting at the store writing out my reviews on the AlphaSmart (god I love this thing), and there hasn’t been a single customer in the doors in the last two hours. Nothing to do for it but be cynical and snarky, I guess... Let’s go! As usual, my comments are in this color, and Jeff's are in red.

ADVENTURES OF SUPERMAN #611: “Hi! We’re the Superman creative team and we haven’t got the foggiest notion of how to tell a Superman story any longer!” I mean, is it even POSSIBLE that the stories can get worse than this? Just like Peter Parker doesn’t belong in space, Superman doesn’t belong in the ‘hood. VP-wife Lana Lang doing porn? Bullshit cop-out people-do-drugs-because-invisible-worms-are-attached-to-them? How COULD this be any worse? If it wasn’t for the dangerously-good Mark Chiarello covers, this would easily be the worst comic of the week... but it was a squeaker. Crap.  I can’t believe they went to such great lengths to create a simultaneous interview approach and they blow it on the bottom of page five.  Good grief.  And it only got worse from there:  that photo session thing with Lana was wrong on every level.  I hated this.  Crap.

AQUAMAN #1:  Boy, this issue made me appreciate Jack Kirby.  When Aquaman is trying to get to the water and is set upon by a bunch of treacherous crabs, and he’s almost killed, you know, by crabs, it seems, surprisingly, pretty lame.  Whereas you know Jack would have come up with some giant crab, or whale-monster with opposable thumbs, or something worthy of a full-page spread.  As for the rest of this,  I think my only real problem was the Internet.  The Arthurian spin Veitch sets up here I already knew about because of an interview with him: I done been spoilerized.  Eh.  My real problem with the Arthurian spin is that... well, it’s a bit obvious, innit? I think ACTUALLY bringing the Lady of the Lake into it is liking asking for more sugar on your chocolate cake. I’m told this first issue is already sold-out nationwide, so I guess it’ll work, but, frankly, I pretty much think Aquaman is an idea that’s great on paper but supremely uninteresting in execution. Maybe, possibly, you can sustain a year’s worth of interest in poor Mr. Curry, but eventually you’re going to end up throwing up your hands and saying, “Shit, wait a minute, it’s AQUAMAN! What was I thinking?!?” Having said all of that, I liked it a bit – a very solid OK.

AVENGERS #61: There were actually some surprisingly deep character bits here – Gyrich actually felt like a real character for once, rather than just “generic government goon”; the Namor and Cap scene was tons of fun; nice tension between Stark and T’Challa; a reasonably believable spin on the Vison and Scarlet Witch romance – all of this adds up to a “Good” rating, but I want to see if the interpersonal stuff can be balanced with action. So far I’m afraid it’s been either/or.  Good point about the either/or, Bri.  I missed the previous issue, so I’m bummed.  This was all set-up, and kinda interesting but mainly just kinda.  Eh.

BATGIRL #35:  What’s this, DC’s “watch a movie, write a comic book” week?  First, we’ve got the bad Traffic riffs in Adventures of Superman, now The Bourne Identity in Batgirl? The artist tries some interesting panel in a panel narrative flow tricks, and has an arresting page or two, but all of his characters seems to have the same spindly weightlessness to them. And the story was incredibly weak: I expect more from this book.  Awful Yah, Bourne Identity, that’s it... nothing else here but set-up, and for $2.50 Daddy wants a bit more. Eh.

BATMAN FAMILY #7 MR FUN: Good lord, I think I’m going to be sick. “The Mulligan of Death”? Are you serious? Having some guy with a golf-club take down the entire “family” without breaking a sweat pretty much demeans any “heroism” they might have, y’know? This is just a sad sad joke, and I’m terrified anyone greenlit this idea which will clearly be all wrapped up and forgotten next issue. Awful To quote the comic book guy:  Worst. Cover. Ever.  And yet, showing where you and I part ways is, dumb-ass golf-club aide, I liked Mr. Fun, mainly because I like what he was ripped off from:  Frank Miller’s silent bespectacled perfect killer from his first Sin City arc.  So, for me, it was Eh.

BATMAN LEGENDS OF THE DARK KNIGHT #162:  I love Roger Landridge’s art:  the man’s a cartoonist’s cartoonist.  Which may be why, interestingly, he has such trouble with the Batman parts of the story and no problems at all with The Joker’s side.  Considering the two parts of the story are brought together at the end of this issue, I imagine next issue will be downhill from here, but this was good stuff, just to see Landridge in color drawing clowns and classic film comedians.  Ditto your Landridge comments. His Joker is wonderfully maniacal and askew. Hopefully this might lead people to his OTHER clown book: Fred the Clown. Good.

BLACK HOLE #10: I sometimes wonder if the various characters and threads of the narrative will ever come together, but then I start to realize that it simply doesn’t fuckin’ matter. Charles Burns’ art is so damn loverly to look at, and his control of genuinely creepy atmosphere is unmatched by nearly anyone. Sex and angst and alienation, and I wish it came more frequently the the every-two-years-or-so schedule it appears on. Excellent.  Yeah, the first five issues of this, pound for pound, were some of the best comics of the last ten years, but then there was an issue or two that felt repetitive and padded, and now that we’re back on track, I feel both exhilarated and bummed out.  This was an excellent comic, but suffers from comparison with early issues of this title.

BLACK PANTHER #52:  Okay, this issue lost me.  Don’t know quite where, or how, but all of a sudden, after two easy to follow issues, I was out in the dark.  Didn’t matter about the recap page, or how most of the characters keep rehashing Kasper’s dilemma:  either I forgot something relatively crucial or there was more than one new piece of info Priest didn’t tell the readership about.  So for me, this felt more contrived than previously, and more confusing and forced.  But maybe it’s just me.  Eh. Huh, I think it’s just you. Blah blah blah good cop doing “bad”, blah blah blah Internal Affairs. Except for the smidge of spandex I didn’t have any real problem following it. Now CARING about it, on the other hand.... Eh. No, but didn’t that chick from his high school yearbook being his one true love kinda come from outta left field?  Or is my grey matter shot?

CAPTAIN AMERICA #6: One thing you sure can say about John Cassaday’s art is it is painfully loverly to look at. But it all comes down to the fight scene, doesn’t it? All of the pretty art in the world can’t cover up a simplistic story. Or, for that matter, my Eh rating.  That so did nothing for me.  Gorgeous art, but the damn thing’s duller than dirt.  Additionally, as a near-pinko, I found this book almost too painful to read as Cap proclaims that Americans didn’t know what was done in their name before, but know now and “We’ve learned from our mistakes.”  As we gear up for what seems to me to be another war for oil, I wish that was even remotely true.  Beautiful art can’t do it all:  I’m giving this an awful because it was such a time-waster and money-suck.

ELEKTRA #18:  Hmmm, two Elektras in two weeks.  How insane is Marvel’s scheduling?  Like I said last week:  I’m not liking this very much, and somehow this was even more annoying than last issue. I hope that Rucka can just kick it in gear and get to that Bruce Lee in Chinese Connection moment that I want.  Awful.  I found this less annoying than last week’s issue, but maybe because of the awareness they’re way into Karate Kid territory. I think that maybe Rucka wants to write “Killer with  heart of gold”, and so he’s forcing Elektra into that place. At least you got a LITTLE ninja death this issue, even if it wasn’t “sexy”. Eh.

GEN13 #4: While there are (like virtually every other Claremont comic) interesting ideas buried here and there (I think the idea of a comatose superhero who stops time when he comes out of his coma is a potentially intriguing one), but they ARE buried. I don’t like any of the characters, I don’t find the set-up at all compelling. Awful The crumminess of this made my head hurt.  Awful.

GREEN LANTERN #157:  That seemed pretty slight, even by fill-in issue standards.  There’s a few nice touches here and there but seemed very simplistic (the first half read like something out of Spidey Super-Stories, to be honest).  Not truly awful, but I can’t imagine who’d buy it except collectors who want a full run of GL.  You know you’re in for suckage when the first panel says “This happens before GL #148” – at least fit a fill-in to current continuity, folks! I’ll go all the way for the full Awful.

HARLEY QUINN #27: While I didn’t care much for the first part of this new direction, I thought this one really nailed the right “mood” for a villain-based comic. I’m still not convinced there’s any real point to this book – Harley should have stayed a purely-Animated character, but this is a solid step closer. OK.  I agree, I guess, about the villain book but it’s all wrong for Harley it seems to me.  And how many times can someone be shot and fall off a roof in one issue?  There’s some wit in the dialogue (although not as much as the writer seems to think) and I like Nixey’s inks, but this needed a lot of work and overall, this new direction seems like the wrong direction.  Awful.

HATE ANNUAL #3:  I enjoy Bagge’s work when he’s on, but I’m not sure this qualifies:  a strip about Lisa’s Martha Stewart worship feels pretty three years ago to me (the country’s in its vilification stage now, what with “Martha Stewart, Stock Swindler”) and double ditto for the Leeway strips about websites and stock options.  The only thing I really dug were the three hilarious “Rock and Roll Dad” strips.  Bagge’s still incredibly talented but adrift.  I hope he can get ahead of the curve again, where he’s at his most trenchant.  Eh. Thing is, at least this one is ALL comics, without any of those fucking text-pages. Yes, it’s not “cutting edge” any more, but I have a great deal of affection for some of these characters and toothless-Bagge is better than no Bagge at all. Good.

HAWKMAN #10: There’s a kernel of an interesting idea right there at the end (“Hijacking” the eternal reincarnation), but it took 21 pages of incredibly dull “action” to get there. This gets a big “Yeah, yeah, get on with it!” from me. Eh Decent art, an okay premise; why isn’t this working?  I guess because we keep getting told about the “star-crossed lovers” angle but we never really see it.  I don’t get the feeling that Carter and Kendra even like each other, which makes the whole romance angle kinda moot.  This book feels like it’s flailing to me.  Eh.

HUNTER THE AGE OF MAGIC #18:  Well, “The Garden” and a woman called “Eden” aren’t particularly subtle, are they?  And either they’re trying to make this some strange “all-ages” Vertigo book, or Eden has no nipples, neither option of which I like.  Although it’s still competently done, there’s a “who cares?” aspect to it for me:  Tim’s too passive, Eden’s too much a blank slate, and Lily’s the only interesting character and even he’s pretty thin.  This book’s slipped from a good to an OK for me.  Ditto on almost every point. Never, not once, between this series or the two proceeding it, do I feel like they’ve every actually gotten what was interesting about Gaiman’s original mini: growing up magical, with horrific choices in front of you. A very low Eh from me.

IRON MAN #62: Boring is as boring does. I read this less than 24 hours ago, and I STILL had to walk over to the rack to remember what happened this issue. Not, as they say, a good sign. Awful.  I agree.  Must not be my week for reading comics because I just didn’t see the charm in this other than it actually came out during the Christmas season.  Awful.

KILLRAVEN #3:  Despite my initial disappointment, I’m enjoying this:  Davis is spinning a solid enough yarn, even if the story was out of Post-Apocalypse 101 (with a nice hint of relevant social commentary).  It’s not setting me on fire, but compared to the other pickings, it gets a high good from me.  Dunno why, but I really liked this issue – maybe it was the Washington DC background, or the comments from the antagonist after he was defeated, or the spider-octopus-lizard thing at the end, or the African masks, but more than likely it’s just yummy Alan Davis art, and providing some sort of context for the sadly flat character of Killraven. Very Good.

LOUIS RIEL #8: It’s definitely not for everyone, but I suspect when the series is all done, and collected this will be seen a major work, and may well be one of those books that makes into schools and universities. It’s a little hard to get past a few of Chester Brown’s cartooning quirks (the bulbous noses, the big feet) in a biographical context like this, but 3 pages in and you hardly notice any longer. Very good I take a pass, because I’ve been waiting for the trade.

LOVE & ROCKETS VOL 2 #6:  I’m pretty done with Me, For the Unknown but ohmygod there was so much brilliant shit in this issue.  Jaime’s story is gorgeous, as always, but I particularly liked this issue’s, which moves hypnotically from external event to internal imaginings with a steady sinuous tone.  And Beto’s mad Roy Cowboy story, four pages with a 55-panel grid, was awesome and absurd and staggering:  it read as if Dostoyevsky had tried to write a story for Harvey Comics.  Excellent. It’s not my cuppa (we’ve been through this before), but those occasional flashes of sheer loony genius (like “30,000 Hours to Kill”) real show that the Hernandez brothers are really masters of their craft. Very Good.

MARVILLE #3: Just when you think it can’t possibly get worse... it does. The latest “Market Beat” in Comics Retailer magazine has 8 different retailers singling out Marville as a “negative sales surprise”. That’s the highest I can remember for a title in some time. The big joke is that there’s going to be a TP in June. Can you believe that? Worse than Crap See, I don’t utterly hate this, although I would never spend any money on something so amateurish:  I just see it as some sort of karmic balance to the Howard the Duck mini, something I have to put up with for the good stuff Marvel puts out.  As for this issue:  Is this a spoof of Promethea, or is the point of Marville for Bill J. to really share his wisdom?  If so, let me pass along some of mine to him:  use a proofreader, Bill.  You’ve got “quite” instead of “quiet” and “principals” instead of “principles.”  As for the rest of it, it was dull and the arrangement of text on art was hard to read, but at least it’s not Origin II.

MASTERS OF THE UNIVERSE NOREMCVR #1:  Man, that is one ugly cover, and I used to dig Earl Norem way back when.  I’m not sure why I’m reviewing this: it seems pretty review-proof these days since people who are still in to He-Man aren’t going to be bothered by stuff like dopey names, nonsensical actions, and stifling exposition, and will appreciate the lush coloring and almost fetishistic art.  But for those who don’t know squat about the Masters of the Universe and are wondering if you should give this a try, I say:  Nope.  Mighty stinky.  Awful. I am embarrassed to admit I was actually amused by Orko, and the slight hint they might go all Dark Phoenix with him. But other than that, yeppers, Awful.

MEK #2: This fairly neatly erases most of my cringing embarrassment from the last page of issue #1. In fact, this really kinda should have been #1 – I think it sets up the world and the situation more compellingly than the “actual” #1 did. Good.   I don’t know, Bri:  two issues in, and I’m still not getting what bad Mek is being used for by people on the street, if not bad ends.  Also, I’m sorry, but I just don’t think Steve Rolston is the right artist for this: the book seems about as gritty as an issue of Archie.  I like the main character, though, and I like the ideas in the book, no matter how sketchily developed so:  OK.

MEKANIX #3:  I can’t tell, between this and Gen 13, if Claremont was really affected by 9/11 and post-9/11 events, or if he just sees a way to make his work more immediate.  Either way, it creeps me out:  it just gives his characters new platitudes to mouth and makes his work even more shrill, if such a thing was possible.  Dull and awful Jesus, yeah. Nailed that one better than I could. Awful. Plus who was asleep at the wheel and let that “asshole” slip through?

NIGHTWING #76: If Dick wasn’t a cop (and Amy’s partner to boot) this woulda worked so so much better. But the end just makes the whole thing fall to little pieces. Eh.  I like the idea of the all-action approach, but that’s all we’re getting here:  the idea of it.  This seemed like one of those four page action scenes that open superhero stories stretched out to seventeen pages.  The characterization stuff made this OK, I guess, but it didn’t really work, for the reasons you stated.

POINT BLANK #5:  Well, no.  As much as I wanted otherwise, I just don’t buy that at all.  I’m always happy about ultra-grim endings but Brube had more than enough time to build a case to build Grifter’s psychology into what we see here and he just didn’t, so I just rejected it out of hand.  This ended up being five wasted issues, unfortunately, and makes me doubt that Sleeper will turn out well.  Awful.  Again, a simple ditto – this didn’t work at all... even more so because it depends on an intimate knowledge of Alan Moore’s WildC.A.T.S. to even have the barest chance of making any sense whatsoever. Awful.

POWERS #26: “Yadda yadda, Bendis kicks ass”  You’ve heard it before, so I’ll spare you this time. Very Good.  I worry sometimes about the Bendis influence, that people in the industry will try to replicate his success, that we’ll end up with an entire market of books that are all middle.  Because not many writers can do what Bendis does, which is make an issue, like here, where it’s all middle, and write enough clever, naturalistic dialogue that you’re actually reading something.  I could see at least three different kinds of padding in this issue alone, and yet it almost didn’t matter because of Bendis’ skill.  But, as I said, I feel it’s teaching a lot of people a lot of bad habits.  Good.

PUNISHER #19:  As long as you can buy the one big coincidence at the beginning, you’ll like this.  I sure did:  the rustic Rambo action, the conversations between Frank and Joan, even the interaction between Frank and the dog.  Ennis can still do in one issue what most writers can’t seem to do in six, anymore.  Very good. “I washed your grenades while you were asleep...” HAHAHA! Funny and action-packed and even touching... you can’t ask for more from a Punisher comic. Very Good.

STORMWATCH TEAM ACHILLES #6:  Well, I liked that more than the previous issues of this crossover, but I’m still not digging it too much.  To mention him twice in one column, I’m a big fan of Jack Kirby, and Kirby was the biggest cheater in the book when it came to whipping out a convenient new superpower or techno-gizmo to keep the story rolling, but there somehow seems to be a big difference between that and this, where every member of the Achilles force busts out some new absurdly powerful armament to beat The Authority and, in the end, uses a U.N. teleportation device for mass destruction in a way that you know every country of the U.N. would have used by now.  It reminds me of when you’re a kid and you get into the whole “well, I’ve got a bulletproof vest.” “Oh, yeah?  Well, I’ve got bulletproof vest-proof bullets.”  “Oh, yeah? Well, I’ve got a bulletproof vest-proof bullet-proof vest.”  The trick to cheating in comics is to make sure you’re entertaining enough as a result that people don’t mind you cheating.  And this just isn’t that entertaining.  Awful.  Aye, all a big cheat from top to bottom. And not a compelling one. A simple ditto of an Awful.

SUPERMAN ALIENS II GODWAR #4: Not that I ACTUALLY thought they’d keep the alien gestating in Orion, but that seemed a fairly boring way to resolve it all. It’s like they went “Shit, we only have 4 pages left!” I woulda preferred it bursting from Orion’s chest, but him biting the head off it or something more unexpected. Getting a hole punched in your chest shouldn’t kill a “GOD”, after all. Otherwise, a competent ending to a bag-of-cash mandated story. Eh I don’t know…somehow diminishes both Alien license and the New Gods license for me.  “By planting these seeds of doubt, Desaad…” That was Darkseid’s whole reason for this whole thing?  Why not try sending Orion a birthday card, instead?  Awful.

SUPERMAN DAY OF DOOM #4:  I didn’t read parts one through three, but I had to stop after four pages because it breaks my heart seeing Bill Sienkiewicz illustrate crap like this.  One of the characters is a reporter who blames Superman for his bipolar father’s suicide, made in the despair over Superman’s death?  That just strikes me as the dumbest thing ever.  Pass Again, it all comes down to the fight scene. There’s not even any good introspection here. Sadly, Awful.

WAR STORY J FOR JENNY: Horrible spiteful people can be moral, too.  That’s a pretty reoccurring theme in Garth’s work, and he plays it to great strength here. Wonderful art by David Lloyd as well. Very Good You know what?  This is the first War Story I was frustrated with, mainly because it was too short:  Ennis could have made this into a graphic novel of twice the length and it would have worked even better as far as fleshing out the secondary characters.  The conflict between Stark and Page was perfectly detailed, and with each one of these Ennis gets closer to getting his hands around the true horror of war.  This was excellent.

WARREN ELLIS STRANGE KILLINGS BODY ORCHARD #4:  I’m sorry, but this turns my crank.  There’s a bajillion problems with it (difficult to keep track of the number of bad guys and their whereabouts, the incredibly arbitrary magic system, some sloppy art) but unlike Team Achilles, I was entertained; it moved like a bullet train and took all the Matrix effects back to their Hong Kong people-running-on-the-tips-of-trees origins.  I can’t mistake it for great, but I thought it was good fun. Everyone’s allowed one slip each week. There’s yours, Lester. Me, I thought the problems you cited were more like gaping flaws, and I couldn’t turn the pages fast enough to be done with the damn thing. Awful.

For Sake of Completeness, here’s a list of all of the OTHER comics that CE got in this week, that I did NOT read (and, therefore, am unlikely to review!). Note, that in most cases this is limited to 1) Manga, which I try to read as it is collected; 2) “Kids” comics like most of the Archies; 3) titles that were subs-only, either by design or accident; 4) Porno [oh, like you need me to REVIEW it!], 5) Things that looked SO bad on the racks that I didn’t bother, and 6) stuff that I’ve assessed before, and I care so little about that I don’t want to waste my time reading anymore. You decide which is which.

AMELIA RULES #8
ARCHIE AND FRIENDS #65
ARCHIE DOUBLE DIGEST #139
AZRAEL AGENT OF THE BAT #97
BETTY #120
BUZZBOY VOL 1 TP TROUBLE IN PARADISE
CAVEWOMAN RAPTOR #2
COLONIA #8
DEATH & CANDY #3
DRAGON ARMS #1
DUNGEONS AND DRAGONS BLACK AND WHITE #5
EX PARTE #2
FOOTLICKER #1 
GOON #3
HOW TO DRAW COMICS THE EROS WAY #1 
INU YASHA PART 7 #5
KISS RUBI CVR #4
KISSING CHAOS NONSTOP BEAUTY #2 
KNIGHTS OF THE DINNER TABLE ILLUSTRATED #17
MARC HEMPELS NAKED BRAIN #3
NEGATION #13
OH MY GODDESS #93
RADISKULL & DEVIL DOLL RADISKULL HATE CHRISTMAS ONE SHOT
SCOOBY-DOO #67
SEXY ANGEL #1
SIGIL #31
SOJOURN #18
SPIDER-MAN LEGEND OF THE SPIDER CLAN #3
STAR WARS REPUBLIC #47
STAR WARS TALES #14
TRANSFORMERS WAR WITHIN #3
TUESDAY #2
WARLANDS VOL 3 #1

And, for even MORE completeness sake, here’s a list of books, TPBs, GNs, magazines, and other things that CE got this week. I generally haven’t read any of this by the time I post these reviews. Though I generally attempt to give at least one recommendation amongst the TPBs each week, since I HAVE read the material at SOME point.

2000 AD #1316
2000 AD #1317
ABC WARRIORS VOL 2 GN BLACK HOLE
ALIEN LEGION PIECEMAKER TP
AMY RACECAR VOL 1 TP
ANIMERICA EXTRA JANUARY 2003 VOL 6 #1
ART OF JOSEPH MICHAEL LINSNERHC
ASTRO BOY VOL 9 TP
BIG MAN BY MAZZUCCHELLI TP
CANNON GOD EXAXXION STAGE 1 TP 
CROUCHING TIGER HIDDEN DRAGONGN #1
DAREDEVIL VOL 2 HC
DISCOVERING AMERICA  BY MAZZUCCHELLI TP
DOOFUS OMNIBUS
ELEKTRA VOL 1 INTROSPECT TP
FABLES LEGENDS IN EXILE TP
FARSCAPE NEWSTAND ED #10
FORTEAN TIMES #165
G FORCE ANIMATED TP
GREYSHIRT INDIGO SUNSET TP
HTDM PUTTING THINGS IN PERSPECTIVE
JADE SCREEN VOL 1 #2 
JUDGE ANDERSON DEATHS DARK DIMENSION GN
JUSTICE LEAGUE ANIMATED BATMAN MAQUETTE
KABUKI VOL 6 SCARAB TP
LEES TOY REVIEW DEC 2002 #122
MAD XL #19
METABARONS ALPHA OMEGA GN
MINERVA VOL 1 
MOONSTONE NOIR HAT SQUAD GN
NEW GENERATION OF MANGA ARTISTS VOL 2
PROMETHEA BOOK TWO TP
PSH SERIES I MON EL & LIGHTNING LAD
SFX #98
STORY OF TAO GN #1
TANK GIRL VOL 3 GN 
TOMARTS ACTION FIGURE DIGEST DEC 2002
TOYFARE WOLVERINE TOY CVR #66
VIDEO GIRL AI VOL 5 TP SPINOFF
WEREWOLF APOCALYPSE FIANNA GN
WIZARD POSTERMANIA 2003

This Week’s TP recommendation is: Dammit, why couldn’t those Mazzuchelli trades be in English?  They’re gorgeous.  I guess I should just be glad Promethea Book Two is finally out in softcover, because it’s brilliant.  Agreed, Promethea is great stuff, but, as a book, it doesn’t really work all that well all on it’s own. I think I’ll give my nod to the Daredevil Vol 2 HC (featuring Bendis and Maleev’s #26-37)... my only question? Um, what’s Vol 1?

Pick of the Week:  Either Love & Rockets V2 #6 or War Story:  J For Jenny, which only wanted from lack of space. Both worthy choices (helluva a week for alt comics), but I think I’ll go with the man-I-wish-this-came-out-more-often Black Hole #10. Good Job!

Pick of the Weak:  Jeezis, anything with Superman in it this week, it seems like.  But I’ll give it to Adventures of Superman #611 because it makes a travesty out of both the characters and the idea of relevant comics.  C’mon. Batman Family #7 sucked way worse than that... and Marville #3 sucked even worse than both of those. Shame on you!

 


  All Material on this page: © 2001-2005 by Comix Experience (except the graphic, which was appropriated from Tales of Suspense #21,
and is probably © Marvel Comics).  Reproduction without permission is expressly forbidden.